Photos for OS X is an incredible step up from its predecessor. Photos for OS X, combined with iCloud Photo Library, is a perfect representation of Apple’s classic “It Just Works” ideal. All of this happens without me needing to do any maintenance or manual syncing. If I take a series of pictures, then go back and curate them (regardless of when or on which device I do this curation), the ones I delete are deleted from all my devices, and the ones I edit are edited on all my devices. When I take a new picture on my iPhone, it is immediately, automatically added to my iCloud Photo Library. This was resolved with a back-end workaround, but I can’t consider this a full solution.īottom line: I can easily recommend Photos, but you’re taking a chance with iCloud Photo Library.Īlex Guyot at MacStories had a better experience with Photos and iCloud: And even that was only possible because I asked Apple about it for this review, and the company (with my permission) analyzed my library and found a “rare bug” it says it had never seen before. While syncing my locally stored photo library, the cloud service failed to do its job properly.Įven though my iPhoto library of 18,000 images isn’t considered large by Apple standards, and my home Internet is speedy in both directions, my library took nearly three days and nights to upload to the cloud - far longer than Apple estimated. It’s faster, easier to use, and has a more modern feel.Īlas, my positive feelings about Photos on the Mac didn’t extend to iCloud Photo Library. I’ve been testing the new Photos app on two different Macs, and I consider it a big improvement over iPhoto. Walt Mossberg reviewed Photos for Recode and ran into a snag with iCloud:

Beware the 9 warning signs of bad IT architecture and see why these 10 old-school IT principles still rule.

Photos app for mac yosemite